Dysorthographie.fr a media powered by

the no.1 media on Dys disorders

Dysorthographia exercise: a or à

“Il a faim” or “il à faim”? “Je vais à l’école” or “je vais a l’école”? Confusing “a” and “à” is one of the most common errors, especially among children with dysorthographia. A simple tip nonetheless resolves it almost every time. Here are some exercises to learn it, then to use it without thinking.

Two words that sound the same

“a” without an accent is the verb to have conjugated: “il a un chat”. “à” with an accent is a preposition, which indicates a place, a time or a manner: “il va à Paris”, “à midi”, “à pied”. When spoken, nothing distinguishes them.

To choose, the child must understand the word’s role in the sentence, which requires grammatical reflection. A child with dysorthographia, already busy transcribing sounds, often forgets to make this check. A quick tip spares them from having to reason at length. The page mon enfant confond les homophones presents the problem more broadly.

The avait trick

To know whether to write “a” or “à”, replace the word with “avait”. If the sentence still makes sense, it is the verb to have, without an accent: “il a faim” becomes “il avait faim”. If the sentence no longer makes sense, it is the preposition, with an accent: “il va avait Paris” is not said.

The cases where it fails are very rare. It can be written on a small card, with an example for each case. The child keeps it in their pencil case and consults it when hesitating. Over the weeks, they will do the test in their head.

Practise orally first

Before writing, one can practise the test aloud. The adult says a sentence, the child repeats it replacing with “avait” and says whether it works. This quick game can be played in the car or at the table.

Speaking allows the child to concentrate on the reasoning without the burden of writing. They understand the logic of the tip. Once they have mastered it orally, one moves on to writing. This step is often overlooked, although it is essential.

The only online directory dedicated to professionals working with Dys disorders

Everyday fill-in-the-gap sentences

Next, fill-in-the-gap sentences are offered, where the child must write “a” or “à”. They do the “avait” test for each sentence, under their breath. One starts with five sentences, with very simple examples.

One can draw on the child’s life to make the exercise concrete: “Lucas … un vélo rouge”, “Nous allons … la piscine”. Sentences that concern them interest them more. The difficulty is gradually increased. The page apprendre les homophones grammaticaux offers other leads.

A card game

One can make a game with cards bearing fill-in-the-gap sentences, and two counters, one marked “a”, the other “à”. The child draws a card, reads the sentence, does the test and places the correct counter. A point is scored for each correct answer.

The game can be played by two people, each reading the other’s cards. The child loves catching the adult out with difficult sentences. This questioner role forces them to think about the rule. Find more game ideas in our page on playful exercises.

Hunting for isolated a

After writing a text, the child can reread it looking for all isolated “a”. For each one, they do the “avait” test. This targeted, quick rereading avoids many errors.

This point can be added to their proofreading checklist for a few weeks. When it becomes automatic, it is replaced by another homophone. The child progresses step by step. We explain how to build this checklist on the page about proofreading.

When the confusion persists

If the child continues to confuse “a” and “à” despite the tip, they may struggle to analyse the sentence. The speech and language therapist can work on grammar in greater depth. These exercises help, but do not replace follow-up if the difficulty is significant.

To find a speech and language therapist, consult the directory ProfessionnelsDys, which allows searching by town and by disorder. It is useful to show them errors from recent writing. The page on the pair et ou est presents another frequent homophone.

Exchange with parents of dys children

A space for exchange, listening and support dedicated to parents of children with DYS disorders

Questions that keep coming up

How to tell whether to write a or à ?

Replace it with avait. If the sentence still makes sense, write a without an accent. Otherwise, write à.

Why start with speaking ?

To understand the logic of the tip without the burden of writing, before applying it in writing.

How many sentences per session ?

Five sentences are enough at the start, with simple examples, before increasing the difficulty.

Discover the articles recently published

Advice, favourites and DYS news every week.

Subscribe here.

Dysorthographie.fr

A media outlet from the LesDys.fr group

The No. 1 media on DYS disorders