When a child with dysorthographia accumulates difficulties, the question of grade repetition may arise. Would repeating a year help them catch up? In the vast majority of cases, the answer is no. Here is why grade repetition is not a solution to a dys disorder, and what is better to put in place. A legitimate question that deserves a clear answer.
In France, grade repetition has become exceptional. It can only be decided in particular situations, after discussion with the family and the setting up of a support arrangement. It is no longer a common practice.
Research on grade repetition shows that it is often ineffective for most pupils experiencing difficulties, and that it can have negative effects on confidence. Its effects are often disappointing.
For a child with dysorthographia, it is even less suitable. The disorder requires other responses. See what is dysorthographia.
Dysorthographia is a lasting disorder, linked to how the brain functions. Repeating a year does not make the disorder disappear: the child will encounter the same difficulties, with the same lessons. The disorder remains.
The problem is not a lack of time to learn, but a different way of learning. What helps is remedial therapy and adjustments, not identical repetition. It is the support that matters.
A dys child who repeats a year without adapted support risks living through the same difficult year a second time. That would be a double penalty.
Grade repetition can be experienced as a failure by the child. They find themselves separated from their friends, with younger children, and may feel less capable. This experience can be difficult.
For a child with dysorthographia, whose confidence is often already fragile, this feeling can be particularly heavy. Their confidence is already fragile.
It can reinforce the idea that they are « hopeless », when they simply need to learn differently. Above all, they need adapted support. See dysorthographia and self-esteem.
The only online directory dedicated to professionals working with Dys disorders
Rather than grade repetition, several solutions are more effective. Speech and language therapy works directly on the child’s difficulties. It tackles the root of the problem.
School adjustments, formalised in a PAP, allow the child to follow the curriculum with adaptations: spelling not penalised outside French, reduced copying, adapted dictations. These adjustments are effective.
Personalised support in class, in a small group, can also help. This support is valuable. See PAP and dysorthographia.
Sometimes grade repetition is considered because the difficulties have not been understood. A child struggling with spelling is judged « not ready » for the next class. A diagnosis changes the perspective.
If your child is in this situation, first ask for a speech and language assessment. A diagnosis can completely change the way their difficulties are approached. It is the first step.
See how to tell if my child is dysorthographic. Understanding is the best way to help.
If the school proposes grade repetition, ask to discuss it. Present the diagnosis and the possible adjustments, and ask about the expected benefits. Dialogue is essential.
You have your say in this decision. Routes of appeal exist if you do not agree. Your opinion matters.
In any case, the essential thing is that the child benefits from adapted support, whatever the class. The support provided is what matters most.
In rare cases, keeping a child back a year may be considered, for example if the child has multiple difficulties, marked immaturity or has been absent for a long time. These situations are rare.
Even in these situations, it must be accompanied by specific support: remedial therapy, adjustments, help. Without this, it is unlikely to be useful. Without support, it is pointless.
The decision must be made case by case, with the opinion of all the professionals who follow the child. Every situation is unique. See who to consult.
A space for exchange, listening and support dedicated to parents of children with DYS disorders
Rarely. Dysorthographia is a lasting disorder that grade repetition does not make disappear. Remedial therapy and adjustments are more effective. Adapted support is more effective.
Speech and language therapy, the adjustments of the PAP and personalised support in class. They tackle the core of the problem.
Yes, you have your say, and routes of appeal exist if you do not agree with the decision. Your opinion matters.
Advice, favourites and DYS news every week.
Subscribe here.
Dysorthographie.fr
The No. 1 media on DYS disorders